[rules-users] Multiple Excel decisiontables - a bug

I think following is a bug and I would like to how different users think Issue: If there are multiple Excel decisiontables files, i.e, NOT multiple decision tables in a single spreadsheet, then the 'fireall' does not necessarily give right results as the rule names get repeated in the resolved drl file. How to produce?: One can produce this issue adding multiple Excel files in Knowledbuilder and also one can see the same problem in Guvnor when one uploads multiple Excel decision tables. Reason for the behavior: The rule name (with row number post fix) gets repeated if all the spreadsheets for the given model. Let us say if I have a model 'com.sample.Test' and two spreadsheet decision tables use this model, then the final resolved drl file would have two rules with the same name, e.g. Test_11 etc. I looked into the code 'org.drools.template.model' and name is not unique between different spreadsheets. If this name is unique, e.g. name of the spreadsheet (presuming each spreadsheet is having unique name), then I do get correct results. I want to know if any one has similar experience or comments. -- View this message in context: http://old.nabble.com/Multiple-Excel-decisiontables---a-bug-tp26408909p26... Sent from the drools - user mailing list archive at Nabble.com.