Paul Ferraro created JGRP-2168: ---------------------------------- Summary: JChannel(Collection<Protocol>) constructor clears protocol properties with non-default converter whose associated system property is not defined Key: JGRP-2168 URL: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/JGRP-2168 Project: JGroups Issue Type: Bug Affects Versions: 4.0.1, 3.6.13 Reporter: Paul Ferraro Assignee: Bela Ban WildFly 11 recently started using the new JChannel(Protocol...) constructor for creating channels. This has resulted in the inability to configure certain protocol properties, most notably, initial_hosts for TCPPING. Because this constructor calls resolveAndAssignFields(...) with an empty map, if a property was explicitly set, and its associated system property does not exist, and that property uses a non-default converter, then it will have its value undefined (or, more specifically, set to whatever the converter does with a null value). Additionally, if the assocated system property did exist, it would take precedence over an explicitly set value. I don't think that's a good idea. Consider the following: {code:java} TCP transport = new TCP(); transport.setBindAddress(InetAddress.getLocalHost()); transport.setBindPort(9600); TCPPING ping = new TCPPING(); ping.setInitialHosts(Collections.singletonList(new IpAddress(transport.getBindAddress(), transport.getBindPort()))); JChannel channel = new JChannel(transport, ping); assert !ping.getInitialHosts().isEmpty() : "No initial hosts!"; {code} Side note: new JChannel(Collection<Protocol>) should really be new JChannel(List<Protocol>), since the collection should be ordered. -- This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v7.2.3#72005)