The order of RHS statements shouldn't affect behavior (insertLogical) --------------------------------------------------------------------- Key: JBRULES-1602 URL: http://jira.jboss.com/jira/browse/JBRULES-1602 Project: JBoss Drools Issue Type: Bug Security Level: Public (Everyone can see) Environment: Drools 4.0.7 & 4.0.4, Java5, eclipse compiler, windows XP. Reporter: Patrick Gras Assigned To: Mark Proctor I have a class 'Cat' that is dynamic (JavaBean with PropertyChangeSupport ) with only a 'name' attribute. Then I have the following rule: rule "test" when $cat:Cat( name == "tom" ) then $cat.setName("cat"); insertLogical(new String("test")); end When I test the rule against a Cat named tom, the logical inserted fact is not retracted. (So the fact is inserted because the rule matches, but is not retracted even if the rule is no more matching at the end.) If I change the order of the RHS, it works fine. The fact is inserted and then retracted. rule "test" when $cat:Cat( name == "tom" ) then insertLogical(new String("test")); $cat.setName("cat"); end So the behavior depends on the ordering of the RHS statements. Here is a complete example to show the problem: public class Cat { private String name; protected PropertyChangeSupport changes = new PropertyChangeSupport(this); public Cat(String name) { super(); this.name = name; } public String getName() { return this.name; } public void setName(String name) { final String oldName = this.name; this.name = name; this.changes.firePropertyChange("name", oldName, name); } public void addPropertyChangeListener(final PropertyChangeListener listener) { this.changes.addPropertyChangeListener(listener); } public void removePropertyChangeListener( final PropertyChangeListener listener) { this.changes.removePropertyChangeListener(listener); } } public class RHSOrderingTest { private static final String PACKAGE = "package ch.generali.pgr.rule "; private static final String IMPORT = "import ch.generali.pgr.rules.Cat "; private static final String WHEN = "rule \"test ok\" when $cat:Cat( name == \"tom\" ) "; private static final String THEN_OK = "then insertLogical(Integer.valueOf(1)); $cat.setName(\"cat\"); end"; private static final String THEN_KO = "then $cat.setName(\"cat\"); insertLogical(Integer.valueOf(1)); end"; private static final String RULE_OK = PACKAGE + IMPORT + WHEN + THEN_OK; private static final String RULE_KO = PACKAGE + IMPORT + WHEN + THEN_KO; private static final String QUERY = "query \"My test Integer\" integer : Integer( intValue == 1 ) end"; public static void main(String[] args) { boolean ok_1 = testWithRule(RULE_OK); boolean ok_2 = testWithRule(RULE_KO); System.out.println((ok_1 ? "SUCCESS: " : "FAILED: ") + THEN_OK); System.out.println((ok_2 ? "SUCCESS: " : "FAILED: ") + THEN_KO); } private static boolean testWithRule(String rule) { Cat tom = new Cat("tom"); RuleBase rb = createRuleBase(rule + "\n" + QUERY); WorkingMemory wm = rb.newStatefulSession(); wm.insert(tom, true); wm.fireAllRules(); QueryResults results = wm.getQueryResults("My test Integer"); return results.size() == 0; } private static RuleBase createRuleBase(String rules) { try { RuleBase ruleBase = RuleBaseFactory.newRuleBase(); PackageBuilderConfiguration conf = new PackageBuilderConfiguration(); PackageBuilder packageBuilder = new PackageBuilder(conf); Reader source = new StringReader(rules); packageBuilder.addPackageFromDrl(source); Package pkg = packageBuilder.getPackage(); ruleBase.addPackage(pkg); return ruleBase; } catch (Exception e) { throw new RuntimeException(e); } } } -- This message is automatically generated by JIRA. - If you think it was sent incorrectly contact one of the administrators: http://jira.jboss.com/jira/secure/Administrators.jspa - For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira