[jboss-jira] [JBoss JIRA] (WFLY-4558) Use "increment" @Schedule for minute require specify hour, for second require specify hour and minute

Use "increment" @Schedule for minute require specify hour, for second require specify hour and minute ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Key: WFLY-4558 URL: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/WFLY-4558 Project: WildFly Issue Type: Bug Components: EJB Affects Versions: 8.2.0.Final Reporter: Matteo Mortari Priority: Minor Attachments: 20150425.WFLY-4558.zip I will attach reproducer and from my perspective workaround exists. If I {{@Schedule}} like this {code} @Schedule(minute="*/1", persistent=false) // NOT working. {code} is not working. But if I do like this: {code} @Schedule(hour="*", minute="*/1", persistent=false) // this works OK. {code} it works. In the specs (1) there is no mention that if I schedule using "Increments" option do I need to specify any of the other elements, because in general _All elements of this annotation are optional._ The problem is applying analogously if using "Increments" option for the {{second}} element, you need to specifiy {{hour}} and {{minute}} to have it working. So, while I anyway in my perspective workaround exists - specify star {{"*"}} for hour or minute-and-hour for setting increments at minute or second respectively - I believe this behavior was not fully adherent to the specs and worth notifying, also I've taken liberty not to leave this jira priority as high, which was by default =) The attached reproducer should be self-explanatory, the most important is the EJB being scheduled: {code} @Schedule(minute="*/1", persistent=false) public void settingJustMinute() { LOG.info("settingJustMinute() : invoked."); // NOT working } @Schedule(hour="*", minute="*/1", persistent=false) public void settingEveryMinuteStarHour() { LOG.info("settingEveryMinuteStarHour() : invoked."); // is working OK. } @Schedule(second="*/1", persistent=false) public void settingJustSecond() { LOG.info("settingJustSecond() : invoked."); // NOT working } @Schedule(minute="*", second="*/1", persistent=false) public void settingEverySecondStarMinute() { LOG.info("settingEverySecondStarMinute() : invoked."); // NOT working } @Schedule(hour="*", second="*/1", persistent=false) public void settingEverySecondStarHour() { LOG.info("settingEverySecondStarHour() : invoked."); // NOT working } @Schedule(hour="*", minute="*", second="*/1", persistent=false) public void settingEverySecondStarMinuteStarHour() { LOG.info("settingEverySecondStarMinuteStarHour() : invoked."); // is working OK. } {code} Hope this helps, Thank you Ciao (1) https://docs.oracle.com/javaee/7/api/javax/ejb/Schedule.html