[jboss-jira] [JBoss JIRA] Commented: (JBCACHE-938) OptimisticNodeInterceptor may NPE if node cannot be created

OptimisticNodeInterceptor may NPE if node cannot be created ----------------------------------------------------------- Key: JBCACHE-938 URL: http://jira.jboss.com/jira/browse/JBCACHE-938 Project: JBoss Cache Issue Type: Bug Security Level: Public(Everyone can see) Affects Versions: 2.0.0.ALPHA2 Reporter: Elias Ross Assigned To: Manik Surtani Fix For: 2.0.0.BETA2 ... else { // "fail-more-silently" patch thanks to Owen Taylor - JBCACHE-767 if ((ctx.getOptionOverrides() == null || !ctx.getOptionOverrides().isFailSilently()) && MethodDeclarations.isPutMethod(m.getMethodId())) { throw new CacheException("Unable to set node version for " + getFqn(args) + ", node is null."); } /* [1] */ } switch (m.getMethodId()) { case MethodDeclarations.putDataMethodLocal_id: Boolean erase = (Boolean) args[3]; cache.getNotifier().notifyNodeModified(fqn, true, CacheListener.ModificationType.PUT_MAP, workspaceNode == null ? null : workspaceNode.getData() , false); putDataMap((Map<Object, Object>) args[2], erase, workspace, workspaceNode); cache.getNotifier().notifyNodeModified(fqn, false, CacheListener.ModificationType.PUT_MAP, workspaceNode.getData(), false); // ^^^ NPE on workspaceNode.getData() break; ... If the node fails to be created or located, the "workspaceNode" variable may be null. The first "? :" check checks for a null condition. The second does not. I don't believe notification should take place if there is no workspaceNode to modify. The solution might be to have notifyNodeModified() take a Node and not a Map. Then, this method code check for the null case. Though, I think in general, it's bad to have the code try and handle this edge case, as most maintainers might not expect workspaceNode to be null during the manipulation steps. Perhaps an ELSE statement could be put in [1] to abort this method gracefully?