[jboss-jira] [JBoss JIRA] (WFLY-12854) Consider to allow non-resuable metrics of the same name in subdeployments

[ https://issues.redhat.com/browse/WFLY-12854?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugi... ] Ivan Straka updated WFLY-12854: ------------------------------- Description: If two method annotated to use MP Metrics have same name. In case of _Counters_ (example): * They are reusable there is actually one MP metric and both method invocation are counted to a single metric. * They are non-reusable: ** They are in the same deployment - ERROR is logged and metrics are not registerd ** They are in different deployments *** (X) MP Config _mp.metrics.appName_ is used thus metrics are registered under _configured_name;_app=the value_ thus they are registered under different name *** MP Config _mp.metrics.appName_ is not used - ERROR is logged and metrics are not registerd Now I'd like to talk about the (X) option. This is valid for two scenarios: * Multiple deployments * Deployment with sub-deployments. In Multiple deployments I am able to to annotate two methods with non-reusable metric of the same name. I need to set MP Config _mp.metrics.appName_ property. Then I can select the metric using a tag. However per https://github.com/smallrye/smallrye-metrics/issues/216 I am not able to do that in deployment with sub-deployments scenario. This is inconsistent behavior and it would be good to have it implemented. was: If two method annotated to use MP Metrics have same name. In case of _Counters_ (example): * They are reusable there is actually one MP metric and both method invocation are counted to a single metric. * They are non-reusable: ** They are in the same deployment - ERROR is logged and metrics are not registerd ** They are in different deployments *** (X) MP Config _mp.metrics.appName_ is used thus metrics are registered under _configured_name;_app=the value_ thus they are registered under different name *** MP Config _mp.metrics.appName_ is not used - ERROR is logged and metrics are not registerd Now I'd like to talk about the (X) option. This is valid for two scenarios: * Multiple deployments * Deployment with sub-deployments. In Multiple deployments I am able to to annotate two methods with non-reusable metric of the same name. I need to set MP Config _mp.metrics.appName_ property. Then I can select the metric by a tag. However per https://github.com/smallrye/smallrye-metrics/issues/216 I am not able to do that in deployment with sub-deployments scenario. This is inconsistent behavior and it would be good to have it implemented. -- This message was sent by Atlassian Jira (v7.13.8#713008)