2:11 a.m.
Greetings:
I am a graduate student working on rules based systems in design. I had a
very fundamental (theoretical) question
on rules usage and would appreciate if you could be so kind as to help.
Consider a hypothetical university application that has the following
objects:
GradStudent
GradStudentRecord (which contains details such as GPA etc.)
GIven the above(and based on the drools docs I have read so far)
I can write a rule as:
when GradStudent.Record.GPA > 3 then student.standing = good
So far everything is okay.
Now consider the case where the University decides to have PhD Students.
Note that there are no PhDStudent objects in the application yet but
I wish to have a rule such as:
when PhDStudentRecord.GPA > 3.5 then student.standing = good
Does the above scenario mean that I would have to code the application
and add an extra PhDStudent object before I can write a rule ?
In other words, is the following proposition true?
Proposition: if there are N objects in an application, and I wish to use
JBoss rules then the rule can be written only "in terms" of the N objects.
If there is a rule to be written for a new (K+1)th object, I would have to
first code
that new object in the application and then write the rule.
I would appreciate if anyone could validate my thoughts above.
Sincerely,
Anup
GradStudent
Michigan Tech.
2:20 p.m.
hi anup,
In general the rule engine can work only on what the system knows. So, the
rules are written for objects that are going to be inserted into the working
memory. So, until an object of type "Foo" is created, no rule that is based
on object "Foo" will be executed.
In your example, seems to me that PhD. grad is a derived class of grad
student. So, you will create another rule for Ph.D grad GPA > 3.5. If you
are trying to represent PhD. grad inside Grad student object without
creating an object for Ph.D grad, then you will need to further refine your
grad student rule to have the check for not Ph.D. and Ph.D. student.
when "grad is not Phd"
Grad ( GPA > 3.0, isPhD == false )
then
System.out.println("Grad is in good standing");
end
when "grad is Phd"
Grad ( GPA > 3.5, isPhD == true )
then
System.out.println("Grad is in good standing");
end
HTH,
Krishnan.
On 6/2/07, Anup Joshi <arj.joshi(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Greetings:
I am a graduate student working on rules based systems in design. I had a
very fundamental (theoretical) question
on rules usage and would appreciate if you could be so kind as to help.
Consider a hypothetical university application that has the following
objects:
GradStudent
GradStudentRecord (which contains details such as GPA etc.)
GIven the above(and based on the drools docs I have read so far)
I can write a rule as:
when GradStudent.Record.GPA > 3 then student.standing = good
So far everything is okay.
Now consider the case where the University decides to have PhD Students.
Note that there are no PhDStudent objects in the application yet but
I wish to have a rule such as:
when PhDStudentRecord.GPA > 3.5 then student.standing = good
Does the above scenario mean that I would have to code the application
and add an extra PhDStudent object before I can write a rule ?
In other words, is the following proposition true?
Proposition: if there are N objects in an application, and I wish to use
JBoss rules then the rule can be written only "in terms" of the N objects.
If there is a rule to be written for a new (K+1)th object, I would have
to first code
that new object in the application and then write the rule.
I would appreciate if anyone could validate my thoughts above.
Sincerely,
Anup
GradStudent
Michigan Tech.
_______________________________________________
rules-users mailing list
rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org
https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users
--
Sivaramakrishna Iyer Krishnan (Anand)
Never assume the obvious is true.
- William Safire
6383
days inactive
6384
days old
1 comments
2 participants
participants (2)
-
Anup Joshi -
Krishnan