RE: [rules-users] order of rules firing

Hi Smitha, The "when" part of rules causes activations to be created on an agenda at the time the facts are asserted. When a call to fireAllRules() is made, activations on the agenda are fired (the "then" part of the rule). The order in which the activations are executed is governed by "conflict resolution" strategies. If you want the "then" part of your rules to fire in a certain sequence look at "salience" (the simplest form), or Agenda Groups and RuleFlow (in increasing levels of complexity). Good luck - JBoss Rules (or whatever new name it might be given - Mark?) is an excellent product that I am sure you will enjoy using. With kind regards, Mike ________________________________ From: rules-users-bounces(a)lists.jboss.org [mailto:rules-users-bounces@lists.jboss.org] On Behalf Of Smitha Bhat Sent: 05 July 2007 16:43 To: rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org Subject: [rules-users] order of rules firing Hi, I am new to JBoss rules. My drl file is not resulting in the functionality that I am expecting. I know that I shouldn't be counting on the rules firing in a particular order, but I find that as I debug my code, the 'when' of the 3 rules are evaluated first, and then the 'then's. For eg. the SetWatch gets called after DistanceKm(Rule1), DistanceKm(Rule2) and CountWatching(rule3) are called. I expected SetWatch to get called after DistanceKm of Rule2 got called i.e. I expected the 'when' and the 'then' to get evaluated sequentially. Is my understanding wrong? I tried setting the salience of the 3 rules, but I get the same behaviour. Is there something else I need to do, to get the functionality I need? Thanks The 3 rules in my drl as given below. rule "Rule1" when $GeoPosition1 : GeoPosition() $GeoPosition2 : GeoPosition() eval(util.StringEqual($GeoPosition1.getType(), "PRPT")) eval(util.StringEqual($GeoPosition2.getType(), "SI")) eval(util.DistanceKm($GeoPosition1, $GeoPosition2) > 100.0) eval(util.Watching($GeoPosition1, $GeoPosition2)) then util.ClearWatch($GeoPosition1, $GeoPosition2); end rule "Rule2" when $GeoPosition1 : GeoPosition() $GeoPosition2 : GeoPosition() eval(util.StringEqual($GeoPosition1.getType(), "PRPT")) eval(util.StringEqual($GeoPosition2.getType(), "SI")) eval(util.DistanceKm($GeoPosition1, $GeoPosition2) <= 100.0) eval(! util.Watching($GeoPosition1, $GeoPosition2)) then util.SetWatch($GeoPosition1, $GeoPosition2); end rule "Rule3" when $GeoPosition1 : GeoPosition() eval(util.StringEqual($GeoPosition1.getType(), "PRPT")) eval(util.CountWatching($GeoPosition1) >= 1) then util.SetThreat($GeoPosition1, 1.0); util.SetColor($GeoPosition1, "red"); end ________________________________ Got a little couch potato? Check out fun summer activities for kids. <http://us.rd.yahoo.com/evt=48248/*http://search.yahoo.com/search?fr=oni _on_mail&p=summer+activities+for+kids&cs=bz>