Version 5.2.0.Final. I have a DRL file that is loaded into my server using a change set and Spring configuration. The file loads without error, and I am able to read the compiled package and print the rule names to confirm they did load; however, only one of the rules fires. Then I copy (hot-deploy) the same DRL file to its server-side directory, and the Resource change Scanner picks it up and reloads it. After reload, all the expected rules execute. My guess is that the Spring/KnowledgeAgent compilation is different than the one done via the resource change scanner. Has anyone else seen this behavior? Any suggestions for further trouble shooting? I can attach the change set, spring config and drl file if needed. -- View this message in context: http://drools.46999.n3.nabble.com/Compiled-rules-differ-KnowledgeAgent-vs... Sent from the Drools: User forum mailing list archive at Nabble.com. _______________________________________________ rules-users mailing list rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users

The spring configuration we use does include all the rules files (I was incorrect to call it a change set - it's not a true changeset file - it's all spring config xml). I will paste the xml here. The file in question is the one named documentListTable.drl. I understand that the load process will be different between spring initial load and resource scanner diff/reload, but if the drl file has identical contents, it seem to me the end result should be identical, i.e. the same rules would fire under the same conditions in both cases. However, for this one drl file that is not what happens. <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> <beans xmlns="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:drools="http://drools.org/schema/drools-spring" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans/spring-beans-3.0.xsd http://drools.org/schema/drools-spring http://drools.org/schema/drools-spring.xsd"> <drools:resource-change-scanner id="droolsChangeScanner" interval="30"/> <drools:grid-node id="droolsClusterNode1"/> <drools:kbase id="workflowKnowledgeBase" node="droolsClusterNode1"> <drools:configuration> <drools:consequenceExceptionHandler handler="com.abclegal.rules.utility.RulesConsequenceExceptionHandler"/> </drools:configuration> </drools:kbase> <drools:kbase id="persistedKnowledgeBase" node="droolsClusterNode1"> <drools:configuration> <drools:consequenceExceptionHandler handler="com.abclegal.rules.utility.RulesConsequenceExceptionHandler"/> </drools:configuration> </drools:kbase> <drools:kbase id="activityKnowledgeBase" node="droolsClusterNode1"> <drools:configuration> <drools:consequenceExceptionHandler handler="com.abclegal.rules.utility.RulesConsequenceExceptionHandler"/> </drools:configuration> </drools:kbase> <drools:kbase id="instructionsKnowledgeBase" node="droolsClusterNode1"> <drools:configuration> <drools:consequenceExceptionHandler handler="com.abclegal.rules.utility.RulesConsequenceExceptionHandler"/> </drools:configuration> </drools:kbase> <drools:kbase id="validationKnowledgeBase" node="droolsClusterNode1"> <drools:configuration> <drools:consequenceExceptionHandler handler="com.abclegal.rules.utility.RulesConsequenceExceptionHandler"/> </drools:configuration> </drools:kbase> <drools:kbase id="invoiceKnowledgeBase" node="droolsClusterNode1"> <drools:configuration> <drools:consequenceExceptionHandler handler="com.abclegal.rules.utility.RulesConsequenceExceptionHandler"/> </drools:configuration> </drools:kbase> <drools:kagent id="workflowKnowledgeAgent" kbase="workflowKnowledgeBase" new-instance="false"> <drools:resources> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/preprocessing/trackedDocuments.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/workflow.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/addressValidation.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/documentList.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/documentListTable.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/filingFees.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/partners/setPartner.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/partners/setReturnPartner.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/serviceStepEvaluation.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/serviceCompleted.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/notServedConsequences.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/setNonServiceType.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/rulesJobSchedule.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="Schedule"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/statusChanges.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/stepCreation.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/investigation/investigation.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/applyServiceRequirements.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/attachedFiles.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/accounting/products.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/accounting/futureProducts.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/accounting/products.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/accounting/productBilling.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/accounting/productLocation.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/payments/payments.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/payments/payServiceAttemptBase.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/payments/payServiceAttemptAdjustments.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/payments/payItemCostAllocation.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/payments/prepayment.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/cancellationConsequences.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/investigation/addressScoring.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="PKG" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/venue/venueSelection.pkg"/> <drools:resource type="PKG" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/venue/venueSelectionLosAngeles.pkg"/> <drools:resource type="PKG" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/venue/venueSelectionFL.pkg"/> </drools:resources> </drools:kagent> <drools:kagent id="persistedKnowledgeAgent" kbase="persistedKnowledgeBase" new-instance="false"> <drools:resources> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/export/customerExport.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/export/documentExport.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/export/invoiceExport.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/export/payExport.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/export/emailExport.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/publish/customerPublish.drl"/> </drools:resources> </drools:kagent> <drools:kagent id="activityKnowledgeAgent" kbase="activityKnowledgeBase" new-instance="false"> <drools:resources> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/editActivity.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/checkpoint.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/generatePrintJobRules.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/generateDocumentRules-docmaker.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/generateDocumentRules-coversheets.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/generateDocumentRules-proofs.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/FilingConfirmationUI.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/ReviewNonServiceUI.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/checkPointServerSuggestions.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/activities.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="activities"/> </drools:resource> <drools:resource type="DTABLE" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/activities/electronicSignatureRules.xls"> <drools:decisiontable-conf input-type="XLS" worksheet-name="DecisionTable"/> </drools:resource> </drools:resources> </drools:kagent> <drools:kagent id="instructionsKnowledgeAgent" kbase="instructionsKnowledgeBase" new-instance="false"> <drools:resources> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/instructions/applyInstructions.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/workflow/documentProductionWorkflow.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/instructions/stepEscalation.drl"/> </drools:resources> </drools:kagent> <drools:kagent id="validationKnowledgeAgent" kbase="validationKnowledgeBase" new-instance="false"> <drools:resources> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/validation/serviceRequirements.drl"/> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/validation/checkPointValidation.drl"/> </drools:resources> </drools:kagent> <drools:kagent id="invoiceKnowledgeAgent" kbase="invoiceKnowledgeBase" new-instance="false"> <drools:resources> <drools:resource type="DRL" source="file:///usr/local/tomcat-rules/webapps/rules/packages/accounting/invoices.drl"/> </drools:resources> </drools:kagent> </beans> -- View this message in context: http://drools.46999.n3.nabble.com/Compiled-rules-differ-KnowledgeAgent-vs... Sent from the Drools: User forum mailing list archive at Nabble.com. _______________________________________________ rules-users mailing list rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users

I think this one is going to be hard to repro in a minimal unit test. our unit tests on this file always run successfully; it's only when deploying into the server with spring and the resource change scanner live that I see the problem. I hesitated to post this one at all to the user forum because I know it will be hard to reproduce. Mostly I wondered if anyone had suggestions to troubleshoot other than what I've already tried. If someone can point me to Drools code to compile the file the way it would happen when Spring loads it, I could test with that and see if I can reproduce the problem. This is how I compile the file for unit testing. Is the compile path different when loaded via Spring? public static KnowledgeBase createKnowledgeBaseFromRulesFile(String path) throws Exception { KnowledgeBuilder kb = KnowledgeBuilderFactory.newKnowledgeBuilder(); try { kb.add(ResourceFactory.newFileResource(path), ResourceType.DRL); } catch (Exception e) { if (kb.hasErrors()) { throw new RuntimeException(kb.getErrors().toString()); } else { throw e; } } if (kb.hasErrors()) { System.out.println(kb.getErrors()); } KnowledgeBase kbase = KnowledgeBaseFactory.newKnowledgeBase(getKnowledgeBaseConfiguration()); kbase.addKnowledgePackages(kb.getKnowledgePackages()); return kbase; } -- View this message in context: http://drools.46999.n3.nabble.com/Compiled-rules-differ-KnowledgeAgent-vs... Sent from the Drools: User forum mailing list archive at Nabble.com. _______________________________________________ rules-users mailing list rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users