Hi all, I had (hopefully) a quick question about trying to test rules in rule flows in Guvnor with Drools 5.1.1. I have a simple 4 step rule flow (Start-RuleGroup1-RuleGroup2-End) with 1 rule in each Rule group. When I set up the test scenario to fire the first rule, which will trigger the second rule, activate “RuleGroup1”, and run the scenario, it doesn’t trigger the RuleFlow and fire the rule. I’ve also tried activating “Start” instead, but neither of them trigger the RuleFlow. I know from experience that Rule Flows don’t seem to work with 5.0, but with the addition of the entry options, I thought they would with 5.1.1. Am I mistaken? Also, when I look at the Audit Log, I see the Rule Flow activated and deactivated before any of the facts are asserted: <Picture (Device Independent Bitmap) 1.jpg> BEFORE RULEFLOW GROUP ACTIVATED group:Start[size=0] <Picture (Device Independent Bitmap) 2.jpg> AFTER RULEFLOW GROUP ACTIVATED group:Start[size=0] <Picture (Device Independent Bitmap) 3.jpg> BEFORE RULEFLOW GROUP DEACTIVATED group:Start[size=0] <Picture (Device Independent Bitmap) 4.jpg> AFTER RULEFLOW GROUP DEACTIVATED group:Start[size=0] <Picture (Device Independent Bitmap) 5.jpg> OBJECT ASSERTED value:com.test.Game@47244724 factId: 1 <Picture (Device Independent Bitmap) 6.jpg> OBJECT ASSERTED value:com.test.Customer@4c584c58 factId: 2 Could this be part of the problem? Thanks! _______________________________________________ rules-users mailing list rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users

Hi Jeff, I met the same problem. I added the rule you mention to Guvnor and it is able to triggered nodes in my ruleflow. However, still no rules were fired. I guess rules are not assigned to ruleflow-groups because it mentions [size=0]. In rules I set up ruleflow-group properties and they work fine in Eclipse. Am I missing something? Following is a part of audit log FIRING rule: [StartProcess] activationId:StartProcess [0] declarations: BEFORE RULEFLOW STARTED process:flow[id=eLearningWF] BEFORE RULEFLOW NODE TRIGGERED node:Start[id=1] process:flow[id=eLearningWF] null process:flow[id=eLearningWF] BEFORE RULEFLOW NODE TRIGGERED node:CorrectInitQuestion[id=2] process:flow[id=eLearningWF] BEFORE RULEFLOW GROUP ACTIVATED group:CorrectInitQuestion[size=0] AFTER RULEFLOW GROUP ACTIVATED group:CorrectInitQuestion[size=0] AFTER RULEFLOW NODE TRIGGERED node:CorrectInitQuestion[id=2] process:flow[id=eLearningWF] null process:flow[id=eLearningWF] AFTER RULEFLOW NODE TRIGGERED node:Start[id=1] process:flow[id=eLearningWF] AFTER RULEFLOW STARTED process:flow[id=eLearningWF] BEFORE RULEFLOW GROUP DEACTIVATED group:CorrectInitQuestion[size=0] AFTER RULEFLOW GROUP DEACTIVATED group:CorrectInitQuestion[size=0] null process:flow[id=eLearningWF] BEFORE RULEFLOW NODE TRIGGERED node:WrongInitQuestion[id=14] process:flow[id=eLearningWF] BEFORE RULEFLOW GROUP ACTIVATED group:WrongInitQuestion[size=0] AFTER RULEFLOW GROUP ACTIVATED group:WrongInitQuestion[size=0] AFTER RULEFLOW NODE TRIGGERED node:WrongInitQuestion[id=14] process:flow[id=eLearningWF] null process:flow[id=eLearningWF] BEFORE RULEFLOW GROUP DEACTIVATED group:WrongInitQuestion[size=0] AFTER RULEFLOW GROUP DEACTIVATED group:WrongInitQuestion[size=0] null process:flow[id=eLearningWF] Does "null process:flow[id=eLearningWF]" indicate anything? Really appreciated if someone can provide some helps. Best, Weilin -- View this message in context: http://drools-java-rules-engine.46999.n3.nabble.com/Test-Scenarios-with-R... Sent from the Drools - User mailing list archive at Nabble.com. _______________________________________________ rules-users mailing list rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users