Hi, everyone, I just find that, insert an event into a entry point or insert it directly into session will cause different behaviour, is this expected? Here is the details: 1. drools run in stream mode and use pseudo clock 2. insert a MyEvent into entry-point "stream" and a MyEvent into session directly every 1 seconds, start at 500ms. 3. call fireAllRules every 1seconds, at second 1, second 2, etc 4. drools version 5.5.0.Final Below is the rule: package me.ycy.drools.test1.data import java.util.List declare MyEvent @role(event) @timestamp(timestamp) end rule "over 0.3s" when $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(300ms)) then System.out.println("Rule: with in 0.3s --> " + $list); end rule "over 1s" when $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(1s)) then System.out.println("Rule: with in 1s --> " + $list); end rule "over 3s" when $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(3s)) then System.out.println("Rule: with in 3s --> " + $list); end rule "over 0.3s ep" when $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(300ms) from entry-point "stream") then System.out.println("Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> " + $list); end rule "over 1s ep" when $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(1s) from entry-point "stream") then System.out.println("Rule: with in 1s use ep --> " + $list); end rule "over 3s ep" when $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(3s) from entry-point "stream") then System.out.println("Rule: with in 3s use ep --> " + $list); end // ------- end of rule Finally, the output(just run 5 seconds) -------------- fire at 1000 --------------- Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] -------------- fire at 2000 --------------- Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500)] Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500)] Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500)] Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500)] Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500)] Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] -------------- fire at 3000 --------------- Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500)] Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500)] Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500)] Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500)] Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500)] Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] -------------- fire at 4000 --------------- Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500)] Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500)] Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500)] Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500)] Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 3,3500)] Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] -------------- fire at 5000 --------------- Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500), MyEvent(event 4,4500)] Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500), MyEvent(event 4,4500)] Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500), MyEvent(event 4,4500)] Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500), MyEvent(event 4,4500)] Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 4,4500)] Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] -- Best regards, Changyuan _______________________________________________ rules-users mailing list rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users

Thank you for your response. I write my code in scala(that's why I don't include code in first post), and use sbt as build tool. I upload the code to github, at https://github.com/yuchangyuan/drools-test1s , so just clone the repo to get the code. sbt 0.13 should be installed(see http://www.scala-sbt.org/ for howto install) before the code can be built and run, after install sbt, just type 'sbt run' in project root directory(the directory contain 'build.sbt' file) to compile and run the code. For drools 5.6.0-SNAPSHOT, I will try later. On Fri, Oct 4, 2013 at 6:56 PM, Davide Sottara <dsotty(a)gmail.com&gt; wrote: > No, this is not normal. > I could not reproduce it in 5.6.0-SNAPSHOT, however, could you try that > version too, and/or post a full > reproducer - i.e. the exact code you are running? > Hopefully it is already fixed > Thanks > > > > On 10/03/2013 11:11 PM, Yu Changyuan wrote: > > Hi, everyone, > > I just find that, insert an event into a entry point or insert it > directly into session will cause different behaviour, is this expected? > > Here is the details: > > 1. drools run in stream mode and use pseudo clock > 2. insert a MyEvent into entry-point "stream" and a MyEvent into session > directly every 1 seconds, start at 500ms. > 3. call fireAllRules every 1seconds, at second 1, second 2, etc > 4. drools version 5.5.0.Final > > Below is the rule: > > package me.ycy.drools.test1.data > > import java.util.List > > declare MyEvent > @role(event) > @timestamp(timestamp) > end > > rule "over 0.3s" > when > $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(300ms)) > then > System.out.println("Rule: with in 0.3s --> " + $list); > end > > rule "over 1s" > when > $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(1s)) > then > System.out.println("Rule: with in 1s --> " + $list); > end > > rule "over 3s" > when > $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(3s)) > then > System.out.println("Rule: with in 3s --> " + $list); > end > > rule "over 0.3s ep" > when > $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(300ms) from > entry-point "stream") > then > System.out.println("Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> " + $list); > end > > rule "over 1s ep" > when > $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(1s) from > entry-point "stream") > then > System.out.println("Rule: with in 1s use ep --> " + $list); > end > > rule "over 3s ep" > when > $list: List() from collect(MyEvent() over window:time(3s) from > entry-point "stream") > then > System.out.println("Rule: with in 3s use ep --> " + $list); > end > > // ------- end of rule > > Finally, the output(just run 5 seconds) > > -------------- fire at 1000 --------------- > Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] > Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] > Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] > Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 0,500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] > -------------- fire at 2000 --------------- > Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500)] > Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event > 1,1500)] > Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500)] > Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] > -------------- fire at 3000 --------------- > Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500), > MyEvent(event 2,2500)] > Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500), > MyEvent(event 2,2500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event > 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500)] > Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 0,500), MyEvent(event 1,1500), > MyEvent(event 2,2500)] > Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] > -------------- fire at 4000 --------------- > Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event > 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500)] > Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event > 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event > 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500)] > Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 1,1500), MyEvent(event 2,2500), > MyEvent(event 3,3500)] > Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 3,3500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] > -------------- fire at 5000 --------------- > Rule: with in 3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event > 3,3500), MyEvent(event 4,4500)] > Rule: with in 1s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event > 3,3500), MyEvent(event 4,4500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s use ep --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event > 3,3500), MyEvent(event 4,4500)] > Rule: with in 3s --> [MyEvent(event 2,2500), MyEvent(event 3,3500), > MyEvent(event 4,4500)] > Rule: with in 1s --> [MyEvent(event 4,4500)] > Rule: with in 0.3s --> [] > > > > -- > Best regards, > Changyuan > > > _______________________________________________ > rules-users mailing listrules-users@lists.jboss.orghttps://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users > > > > _______________________________________________ > rules-users mailing list > rules-users(a)lists.jboss.org > https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users > -- Best regards, Changyuan