[hibernate-dev] Clever dirty checking for Hibernate Search

Context: As a follow-up on "HSEARCH-361 Only index an entity if an indexed property has changed": during development of this improvement we agreed to disable the dirty-checking optimization in case a BoostStrategy or ClassBridge was defined on the class; we also considered the (unlikely) possibility that a FieldBridge could access the full entity in some way, getting access to properties we wouldn't expect (this case requires to disable the new feature). So to fully support proper dirty check,some ideas where proposed to add some way for ClassBridge/BoostStratey/... to define from which properties they are affected. Even if these implementations could list all property names, there are drawbacks: 1) it breaks DRY. It's error prone, people could easily forget to update the used-properties definition after fixing the main method. 2) doesn't take into account branches in the implementation. Maybe in some cases it's affected by A,B, in some others by A,C depending on the value of A. 3) pollutes all existing APIs. Considering these drawbacks, I'm wondering if instead of the entity we could pass to these implementations a proxied entity which could record exactly which properties are being accessed. The index would be not considered dirty if accessed properties aren't, so further Document processing can be skipped. I'd expect Hibernate core already has all required elements to intercept and track access to managed entities? Cheers, Sanne