I am working wth Alexandre Porcelli on some major changes to the HQL translators. Since the changes are drastic we decided to move from Antlr2 to Antlr3 in the process as Antlr3 offers many benefits over Antlr2. The only concern I have with the move to Antlr3 is the fact that Antlr3 only works with JDK 1.5+. I had planned on incorporating this work into Hibernate 3.5. The obvious question being the corresponding JDK move for Hibernate users migrating to 3.5. Anyone have strong reasons to not do this move in the 3.5 timeframe?

I am working wth Alexandre Porcelli on some major changes to the HQL translators. Since the changes are drastic we decided to move from Antlr2 to Antlr3 in the process as Antlr3 offers many benefits over Antlr2. The only concern I have with the move to Antlr3 is the fact that Antlr3 only works with JDK 1.5+. I had planned on incorporating this work into Hibernate 3.5. The obvious question being the corresponding JDK move for Hibernate users migrating to 3.5. Anyone have strong reasons to not do this move in the 3.5 timeframe?

OK, my email (hibernate.org) is finally back. Perhaps just heard no responses because it was down? Any objections? On Mon, 2009-04-20 at 08:54 -0500, Steve Ebersole wrote: > I am working wth Alexandre Porcelli on some major changes to the HQL > translators. Since the changes are drastic we decided to move from > Antlr2 to Antlr3 in the process as Antlr3 offers many benefits over > Antlr2. > > The only concern I have with the move to Antlr3 is the fact that Antlr3 > only works with JDK 1.5+. I had planned on incorporating this work into > Hibernate 3.5. The obvious question being the corresponding JDK move > for Hibernate users migrating to 3.5. > > Anyone have strong reasons to not do this move in the 3.5 timeframe? > >

Did you see my question/objections/inquiry this time ? :) /max Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: > Hi Steve, > > I asked: > > Is antrl3 capable to coexist with antrl2 in the same classloader/app/vm ? > > p.s. your email steve(a)redhat.com bounces with errors. > > /max > > > Steve Ebersole wrote: >> OK, my email (hibernate.org) is finally back. Perhaps just heard no >> responses because it was down? >> >> Any objections? >> >> >> On Mon, 2009-04-20 at 08:54 -0500, Steve Ebersole wrote: >>> I am working wth Alexandre Porcelli on some major changes to the HQL >>> translators. Since the changes are drastic we decided to move from >>> Antlr2 to Antlr3 in the process as Antlr3 offers many benefits over >>> Antlr2. >>> >>> The only concern I have with the move to Antlr3 is the fact that Antlr3 >>> only works with JDK 1.5+. I had planned on incorporating this work >>> into >>> Hibernate 3.5. The obvious question being the corresponding JDK move >>> for Hibernate users migrating to 3.5. >>> >>> Anyone have strong reasons to not do this move in the 3.5 timeframe? > _______________________________________________ > hibernate-dev mailing list > hibernate-dev(a)lists.jboss.org > https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/hibernate-dev _______________________________________________ hibernate-dev mailing list hibernate-dev(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/hibernate-dev