agreed for all points. about the model, we should modelize what we have today which is rather simple and trivial. We will think about updating it in the future. "sohil.shah(a)jboss.com" wrote : This is a good discussion thread...so far let me summarize the points that we are in agreement on for the UI Server architecture, to push the prototype further | | 1/ the ui server should have its own module that does not depend upon core or theme framework and introduce its own concepts | | 2/ testing it in core should be done using a core-uiserver module (temporary) that reuses core + uiserver module and produce a jboss-portal.sar that mixes both | | 3/ the protocol between the consumer and producer (let's call them like in WSRP) needs to be done really using a protocol modeled under the form of data objects (I am going to describe that in another post). | | 4/ in the core-uiserver part, the current core controller should be reused with with separate implementation of ResponseHandler that would adapt the current core controller command framework to the ui server protocol. | | 5/ The consumer and producer exchange data using a protocol, which simply means that the consumer makes a request, the producer perform something and returns back a response that the consumer should handle. | | 6/ It could be an option, however I would prefer to separate protocol request state from protocol request meta data. On example is that the type of a request is a meta data and I want rather to use a design which use annotations. | | Point still open for discussion: | | Hierarchially how broad should the UIServer Object model be. | | 1/ Should it be slim | | 2/ Should it be an extensible hierarchy of Objects. | | IMO- I prefer an extensible hierarchy of Objects as long as this entire hierarchy is not exposed/exploited on the client side of things, making client side integration code quite complex and not so de-coupled | | What I am suggesting is a simple object based protocol between the Controller layer and the UI Server layer and an extensible hierarchy of UI Objects to be used internally by the UI Server | | Clarification: when I say client side in this case, I mean the Controller layer which is a consumer to the UIServer. | | View the original post : http://www.jboss.com/index.html?module=bb&op=viewtopic&p=4061402#... Reply to the post : http://www.jboss.com/index.html?module=bb&op=posting&mode=reply&a...