2:21 a.m.
Probably sent not at the best of times, this didn't get a peep from anyone.
Please do comment, for the reasons stated below.
-W
On 24 December 2010 11:23, Wolfgang Laun <wolfgang.laun(a)gmail.com> wrote:
This is a summary of the currently implemented new features for the
DSL
expansion. I'll have to add tests and documentation, but before doing so,
I'd like to learn whether there are any objections (resulting in the
removal) or suggestions for improvement. Myself, I'm not sure about one or
two items which I've marked with "(?)". Also, there's a couple of
items
which might gain from easy-to-implement additions, see "Votes, please". An
example showing most of the new options is given below.
1. The right hand side of entry definitions can be empty. (Useful for
deleting "filler" phrases.)
2. Long entry lines can be split without the need of escaping EOL:
- Any line beginning with # or // starts a DSL comment and is not
passed to the DSL parser.
- Any line beginning with '[' starts a new entry.
- All other lines are appended to the preceding line, with a space
replacing EOL.
- Empty lines are inserted to maintain original line numbers, and
line and column numbers in error messages from the parser are recalculated
to reflect the user view of the DSL text.
3. The special comment introduction "#/" is used to mark a line
containing debug options. Currently recognized keywords are:
- result - dumps the resulting DRL
- steps - shows all expansion operations in conditions and
consequences
- keyword, when, then - display the corresponding entry definitions
- usage - shows how often an entry was actually used in an expansion
4. Variable substitution uses the definition of that variable seen last
in the current when or then part expansion. not just from the current line.
(But this probably should keep variables from the when part for the
following then part. Votes, please.)
5. The value used in a variable substitution can be modified on the fly
by adding one of the modifiers after and '!' in the variable reference.
Currently recognized modifiers are:
- uc, lc - convert all letters to upper case or lower case,
respectively
- ucfirst - convert the first letter to upper case, and all other
letters to lower case
- num - extract all digits and a '-' preceding the first digit and
insert the numeric value; a '.' or ',' two digits from the right is
retained
as a decimal point, which is useful for monetary quantitites. (?)
6. Another modification of the value used for substituting the
reference is by providing a "multiple choice" after an '!',
consisting of
strings separated alternatively by '?' and '/': If the string
extracted from
the DSLR line matches the string before a '?', the string following it is
used for substitution; otherwise test the next choice. (?)
7. A DSL value starting with a hyphen ('-') can also be used in a
consequence to add another setter expression into a preceding
"modify(x){}".
(Should probably be extended to be able to handle the insertion of another
parameter to any preceding method call and, as a special, but useful, case
the concatenation to a preceding x.println() or x.print() call. Votes,
please.)
DSL:
[when][][Tt]here is an?=
[when][]{entity} called {x}=
${entity!lc}: {entity!ucfirst}( $name:
name=="{x!M?Mark/E?Edson/G?Geoffrey/unknown}")
[when][]and no other with the same {attr}=not {entity!ucfirst}( {attr} ==
${attr} )
[then][]change person=modify($person)\{\}
[then][]- set {attr} to {value} = set{attr!ucfirst}( {value!num} )
DSLR:
rule "Rule 1"
when
There is a PERSON called M
and no other with the same name
then
change person
- set salary to US$9,999.99
- set rank to "colonel"
end
DRL:
8 rule "Rule 1"
9 when
10 $person: Person( $name: name=="Mark")
11 not Person( name == $name )
12 then
13 modify($person){ setSalary( 9999.99 ), setRank( "colonel" ) }
14 end
Cheers
Wolfgang
10:18 a.m.
Hi Wolfgang,
It looks very good. My only concern is how it affects the eclipse
plugin, specially the line breaks. I am guessing we will have to
change it to support that?
Also, does any of these changes break backward compatibility?
In case it doesn't, my vote is to apply all the changes listed.
Edson
2011/1/3 Wolfgang Laun <wolfgang.laun(a)gmail.com>:
Probably sent not at the best of times, this didn't get a peep
from anyone.
Please do comment, for the reasons stated below.
-W
On 24 December 2010 11:23, Wolfgang Laun <wolfgang.laun(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
> This is a summary of the currently implemented new features for the DSL
> expansion. I'll have to add tests and documentation, but before doing so,
> I'd like to learn whether there are any objections (resulting in the
> removal) or suggestions for improvement. Myself, I'm not sure about one or
> two items which I've marked with "(?)". Also, there's a couple of
items
> which might gain from easy-to-implement additions, see "Votes, please". An
> example showing most of the new options is given below.
>
> The right hand side of entry definitions can be empty. (Useful for
> deleting "filler" phrases.)
> Long entry lines can be split without the need of escaping EOL:
>
> Any line beginning with # or // starts a DSL comment and is not passed to
> the DSL parser.
> Any line beginning with '[' starts a new entry.
> All other lines are appended to the preceding line, with a space replacing
> EOL.
> Empty lines are inserted to maintain original line numbers, and line and
> column numbers in error messages from the parser are recalculated to reflect
> the user view of the DSL text.
>
> The special comment introduction "#/" is used to mark a line containing
> debug options. Currently recognized keywords are:
>
> result - dumps the resulting DRL
> steps - shows all expansion operations in conditions and consequences
> keyword, when, then - display the corresponding entry definitions
> usage - shows how often an entry was actually used in an expansion
>
> Variable substitution uses the definition of that variable seen last in
> the current when or then part expansion. not just from the current line.
> (But this probably should keep variables from the when part for the
> following then part. Votes, please.)
> The value used in a variable substitution can be modified on the fly by
> adding one of the modifiers after and '!' in the variable reference.
> Currently recognized modifiers are:
>
> uc, lc - convert all letters to upper case or lower case, respectively
> ucfirst - convert the first letter to upper case, and all other letters to
> lower case
> num - extract all digits and a '-' preceding the first digit and insert
> the numeric value; a '.' or ',' two digits from the right is retained
as a
> decimal point, which is useful for monetary quantitites. (?)
>
> Another modification of the value used for substituting the reference is
> by providing a "multiple choice" after an '!', consisting of
strings
> separated alternatively by '?' and '/': If the string extracted from
the
> DSLR line matches the string before a '?', the string following it is used
> for substitution; otherwise test the next choice. (?)
> A DSL value starting with a hyphen ('-') can also be used in a consequence
> to add another setter expression into a preceding "modify(x){}". (Should
> probably be extended to be able to handle the insertion of another parameter
> to any preceding method call and, as a special, but useful, case the
> concatenation to a preceding x.println() or x.print() call. Votes, please.)
>
> DSL:
> [when][][Tt]here is an?=
> [when][]{entity} called {x}=
> ${entity!lc}: {entity!ucfirst}( $name:
> name=="{x!M?Mark/E?Edson/G?Geoffrey/unknown}")
> [when][]and no other with the same {attr}=not {entity!ucfirst}( {attr} ==
> ${attr} )
> [then][]change person=modify($person)\{\}
> [then][]- set {attr} to {value} = set{attr!ucfirst}( {value!num} )
>
> DSLR:
> rule "Rule 1"
> when
> There is a PERSON called M
> and no other with the same name
> then
> change person
> - set salary to US$9,999.99
> - set rank to "colonel"
> end
>
> DRL:
> 8 rule "Rule 1"
> 9 when
> 10 $person: Person( $name: name=="Mark")
> 11 not Person( name == $name )
> 12 then
> 13 modify($person){ setSalary( 9999.99 ), setRank( "colonel" ) }
> 14 end
>
> Cheers
> Wolfgang
>
>
_______________________________________________
rules-dev mailing list
rules-dev(a)lists.jboss.org
https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-dev
--
Edson Tirelli
JBoss Drools Core Development
JBoss by Red Hat @ www.jboss.com
1:10 p.m.
On 3 January 2011 16:18, Edson Tirelli <ed.tirelli(a)gmail.com> wrote:
None I'm aware of.
In case it doesn't, my vote is to apply all the changes listed.
OK, which means I'll go ahead and fix the Expert doc.
-W
> Edson
> 2011/1/3 Wolfgang Laun
<wolfgang.laun(a)gmail.com>:
> > Probably sent not at the best of times, this didn't get a peep from
> anyone.
> > Please do comment, for the reasons stated below.
> > -W
> > > On 24 December 2010 11:23, Wolfgang Laun
<wolfgang.laun(a)gmail.com > wrote:
> > > >> This is a summary of
the currently implemented new features for the DSL
> >> expansion. I'll have to add tests and documentation, but before doing
> so,
> >> I'd like to learn whether there are any objections (resulting in the
> >> removal) or suggestions for improvement. Myself, I'm not sure about one
> or
> >> two items which I've marked with "(?)". Also, there's a
couple of items
> >> which might gain from easy-to-implement additions, see "Votes,
please".
> An
> >> example showing most of the new options is given below.
> > > >> The right hand side of
entry definitions can be empty. (Useful for
> >> deleting "filler" phrases.)
> >> Long entry lines can be split without the need of escaping EOL:
> > > >> Any line beginning
with # or // starts a DSL comment and is not passed
> to
> >> the DSL parser.
> >> Any line beginning with '[' starts a new entry.
> >> All other lines are appended to the preceding line, with a space
> replacing
> >> EOL.
> >> Empty lines are inserted to maintain original line numbers, and line and
> >> column numbers in error messages from the parser are recalculated to
> reflect
> >> the user view of the DSL text.
> > > >> The special comment
introduction "#/" is used to mark a line containing
> >> debug options. Currently recognized keywords are:
> > > >> result - dumps the
resulting DRL
> >> steps - shows all expansion operations in conditions and consequences
> >> keyword, when, then - display the corresponding entry definitions
> >> usage - shows how often an entry was actually used in an expansion
> > > >> Variable substitution
uses the definition of that variable seen last in
> >> the current when or then part expansion. not just from the current line.
> >> (But this probably should keep variables from the when part for the
> >> following then part. Votes, please.)
> >> The value used in a variable substitution can be modified on the fly by
> >> adding one of the modifiers after and '!' in the variable
reference.
> >> Currently recognized modifiers are:
> > > >> uc, lc - convert all
letters to upper case or lower case, respectively
> >> ucfirst - convert the first letter to upper case, and all other letters
> to
> >> lower case
> >> num - extract all digits and a '-' preceding the first digit and
insert
> >> the numeric value; a '.' or ',' two digits from the right is
retained as
> a
> >> decimal point, which is useful for monetary quantitites. (?)
> > > >> Another modification
of the value used for substituting the reference is
> >> by providing a "multiple choice" after an '!', consisting
of strings
> >> separated alternatively by '?' and '/': If the string
extracted from the
> >> DSLR line matches the string before a '?', the string following it
is
> used
> >> for substitution; otherwise test the next choice. (?)
> >> A DSL value starting with a hyphen ('-') can also be used in a
> consequence
> >> to add another setter expression into a preceding "modify(x){}".
(Should
> >> probably be extended to be able to handle the insertion of another
> parameter
> >> to any preceding method call and, as a special, but useful, case the
> >> concatenation to a preceding x.println() or x.print() call. Votes,
> please.)
> > > >> DSL:
> >> [when][][Tt]here is an?=
> >> [when][]{entity} called {x}=
> >> ${entity!lc}: {entity!ucfirst}( $name:
> >> name=="{x!M?Mark/E?Edson/G?Geoffrey/unknown}")
> >> [when][]and no other with the same {attr}=not {entity!ucfirst}( {attr}
> ==
> >> ${attr} )
> >> [then][]change person=modify($person)\{\}
> >> [then][]- set {attr} to {value} = set{attr!ucfirst}( {value!num} )
> > > >> DSLR:
> >> rule "Rule 1"
> >> when
> >> There is a PERSON called M
> >> and no other with the same name
> >> then
> >> change person
> >> - set salary to US$9,999.99
> >> - set rank to "colonel"
> >> end
> > > >> DRL:
> >> 8 rule "Rule 1"
> >> 9 when
> >> 10 $person: Person( $name: name=="Mark")
> >> 11 not Person( name == $name )
> >> 12 then
> >> 13 modify($person){ setSalary( 9999.99 ), setRank( "colonel" )
}
> >> 14 end
> > > >> Cheers
> >> Wolfgang
> > > > > > > >
_______________________________________________
> > rules-dev mailing list
> > rules-dev(a)lists.jboss.org
> > https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-dev
> > > --
> Edson Tirelli
> JBoss Drools Core Development
> JBoss by Red Hat @ www.jboss.com
> _______________________________________________
> rules-dev mailing list
> rules-dev(a)lists.jboss.org
> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-dev
Hi Wolfgang,
It looks very good. My only concern is how it affects the eclipse
plugin, specially the line breaks. I am guessing we will have to
change it to support that?
Good catch. I would not expect the Eclipse editor to keep the line breaks,
but it
seems
that it fails to continue reading entries after the first split entry. :-{
Can this be fixed without busting a vein? Given that "Language Expression"
and "Rule
Language Mapping" could both be multiline, the widget structure in the DSL
Editor
would need some rework. But it sure would benefit, too.
(I can't imagine how anybody could edit a complex DSL with this editor. Even
minor
changes in the DSL require you to reorder the entries, and I don't see how
you can
do this in the Eclipse editor. And there's no "find", no
"find/replace",
etc... This
editor just isn't going to clinch it.)
Also, does any of these changes break backward compatibility?
4860
days inactive
4860
days old
2 comments
2 participants
participants (2)
-
Edson Tirelli -
Wolfgang Laun